Choosing between the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Cloud mattresses can be difficult, as both are premium brands offering high-quality options with their own distinct advantages. In this comparison, we’ll dive into the key differences and similarities between the two, covering every aspect from firmness, feel, materials, performance for different sleep positions, price, and more. Whether you’re a back sleeper looking for optimal spinal support or a side sleeper seeking pressure relief, this guide will help you determine which mattress suits your needs.
Beautyrest Black vs. Tempur-Cloud: Overview
Before we break down the details, here is a summary of the key features of both the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Cloud mattresses:
| Feature | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Hybrid (Memory Foam + Innerspring Coils) | All-Foam (Memory Foam Layers) |
| Firmness | Medium-Firm (7/10) | Medium-Firm (7/10) |
| Feel | Bouncy, Responsive | Slow-moving, Contouring |
| Height | 13 inches | 10 inches |
| Temperature Control | Sleeps cooler with gel-infused foam | May retain more heat |
| Edge Support | Reinforced edges | Moderate edge support |
| Motion Isolation | Good, but may transfer more motion | Excellent, isolates motion well |
| Pressure Relief | Average | Good for pressure relief |
| Durability | Durable due to hybrid construction | Long-lasting, but slightly less durable |
| Best For | Back, stomach sleepers, hot sleepers | Back sleepers, couples, memory foam lovers |
| Price Range | $$$$ (Luxury) | $$$$ (Luxury) |
| Warranty | 10-year warranty | 10-year warranty |
| Trial Period | 100 nights | 90 nights |
Construction and Materials
The construction of a mattress plays a key role in determining its comfort, support, and durability. Let’s take a closer look at how the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Cloud mattresses are built.
Beautyrest Black Construction
The Beautyrest Black is a hybrid mattress that combines memory foam layers with an advanced pocketed coil system. Its materials and construction include:
- Antimicrobial Fabric Cover: Prevents odor and bacteria buildup.
- Gel Memory Foam: Helps with pressure relief while keeping the mattress cool.
- Firm Comfort Foam: Provides supportive layers for a balanced feel.
- Energy Foam: Enhances the overall durability of the mattress.
- T3 Pocketed Coil Technology: Responsive innerspring coils that improve motion isolation, provide bounce, and reinforce edge support.
Tempur-Cloud Construction
The Tempur-Cloud is an all-foam mattress, built with layers of memory foam for a classic contouring feel. Its construction includes:
- Moisture-Wicking Stretch Cover: Helps wick away moisture and promote airflow.
- Two Layers of Tempur® Material: Proprietary memory foam that offers slow-moving, pressure-relieving comfort.
- Premium Support Foam Base: Provides foundational support and durability.
| Construction Feature | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Cover | Antimicrobial Fabric | Moisture-Wicking Stretch Fabric |
| Comfort Layer | Gel Memory Foam + Firm Comfort Foam | Tempur® Memory Foam |
| Support System | T3 Pocketed Coil System | Premium Support Foam Base |
| Total Height | 13 inches | 10 inches |
Key Differences in Materials
- Hybrid vs. All-Foam: The Beautyrest Black is a hybrid, which combines both foam and innerspring coils for a balance of support and responsiveness. The Tempur-Cloud is an all-foam mattress, which provides a deeper contouring sensation.
- Temperature Control: The Beautyrest Black tends to sleep cooler due to the gel-infused foam and the airflow facilitated by the innerspring coils. The Tempur-Cloud, being an all-foam model, may retain more heat, which can be a concern for hot sleepers.
Firmness and Feel
Firmness and feel are crucial factors in choosing a mattress, especially for those with specific comfort preferences or sleep position needs. Both the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Cloud are medium-firm mattresses, but they deliver quite different experiences.
Beautyrest Black Firmness and Feel
The Beautyrest Black mattress has a firmness rating of 7/10, making it ideal for back and stomach sleepers. The mattress offers a bouncy, responsive feel due to the pocketed coil system, which provides lift and makes it easier to move around on the surface. The gel memory foam and foam comfort layers give some pressure relief but without the deep sinking sensation of memory foam.
Tempur-Cloud Firmness and Feel
The Tempur-Cloud also falls within the medium-firm range (7/10), but its memory foam feel is entirely different from Beautyrest Black. It provides a slow-moving, hugging sensation that contours to your body, which is especially beneficial for side sleepers who need pressure relief for their shoulders and hips. However, the deep contouring may make it harder for some sleepers to move around.
| Firmness & Feel Factor | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Firmness Level | 7/10 (Medium-Firm) | 7/10 (Medium-Firm) |
| Feel | Bouncy, Responsive | Slow-Moving, Contouring |
| Ease of Movement | Easy to move around due to coils | Less easy to move, deep sink-in feel |
Sleeping Positions and Performance
Your sleeping position and body weight significantly affect how comfortable you’ll find a mattress. Here’s how the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Cloud perform for different sleepers:
| Sleeping Position | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Side Sleepers | Provides decent support for average to heavier side sleepers but may feel too firm for lightweight individuals. | Better for side sleepers, especially lightweight and average-weight individuals, due to excellent pressure relief. |
| Back Sleepers | Ideal for back sleepers of all body types. The firm support keeps the spine aligned. | Suitable for back sleepers, especially lightweight and average-weight individuals. |
| Stomach Sleepers | Offers enough support to prevent hips from sinking, making it a good choice for stomach sleepers. | May be too soft for stomach sleepers, especially heavier individuals. |
Who is the Beautyrest Black Best For?
- Back & Stomach Sleepers: Its firmer feel and pocketed coil technology help maintain spinal alignment, making it ideal for back and stomach sleepers.
- Hot Sleepers: With gel memory foam and breathable innerspring coils, the Beautyrest Black promotes airflow and helps hot sleepers stay cool throughout the night.
- Heavyweight Sleepers: The Beautyrest Black offers the necessary support and durability, with reinforced edge support that provides stability for heavier individuals.
Who is the Tempur-Cloud Best For?
- Side Sleepers: The Tempur-Cloud’s deep contouring and pressure relief make it a better option for side sleepers, especially lightweight and average-weight individuals.
- Couples: With excellent motion isolation, the Tempur-Cloud ensures that you won’t be disturbed by your partner’s movements during the night.
- Foam Lovers: If you love the classic “sink-in” feel of memory foam, the Tempur-Cloud delivers that experience better than the Beautyrest Black.
Performance Comparison
Let’s compare the performance of each mattress across various categories, including motion transfer, temperature control, durability, edge support, and more.
| Performance Metric | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Temperature Control | Sleeps cooler due to gel memory foam and coils. | May retain heat, but cooling covers are available in some models. |
| Motion Isolation | Good, but coils may transfer some motion. | Excellent, ideal for couples. |
| Edge Support | Excellent due to reinforced edges. | Moderate edge support. |
| Pressure Relief | Average pressure relief. | Better pressure relief, ideal for side sleepers. |
| Durability | Highly durable due to hybrid construction. | Durable, but slightly less so than Beautyrest Black. |
Temperature Control
Beautyrest Black performs better in terms of temperature control. Its hybrid construction allows for increased airflow, while the Tempur-Cloud, being an all-foam mattress, may retain more heat. Hot sleepers may prefer the Beautyrest Black for its cooling properties.
Motion Transfer
If motion isolation is important to you, the Tempur-Cloud excels in this area. The memory foam absorbs movement effectively, making it ideal for couples who don’t want to disturb each other during the night. Beautyrest Black offers decent motion isolation but may not be as effective as the Tempur-Cloud due to the bouncier nature of the innerspring coils. While the Beautyrest Black performs well, especially compared to other hybrid mattresses, couples who are highly sensitive to movement might prefer the Tempur-Cloud.
Edge Support
Edge support is important for sleepers who like to sit on the edge of the bed or for couples who want to maximize the mattress surface. The Beautyrest Black excels in edge support due to its reinforced coil perimeter, allowing sleepers to comfortably use the full surface of the mattress without feeling like they’re going to roll off. Tempur-Cloud has moderate edge support, but as an all-foam mattress, it doesn’t offer the same level of stability as a hybrid.
Pressure Relief
For sleepers who need pressure relief, particularly side sleepers, Tempur-Cloud has the upper hand. The slow-moving, contouring memory foam excels at cushioning sensitive areas like the shoulders and hips, making it an ideal choice for those who experience joint pain or need extra relief in pressure points. Beautyrest Black offers decent pressure relief but may not provide the same level of contouring and pressure alleviation as Tempur-Pedic memory foam.
Durability
Both mattresses are built to last, but Beautyrest Black has a slight edge in durability due to its hybrid construction. The combination of foam layers and innerspring coils makes it resistant to sagging over time, and it should last longer than all-foam options, especially for heavier sleepers. Tempur-Cloud is also durable, but memory foam mattresses generally have a shorter lifespan than hybrids, particularly for individuals on the heavier side.
Price Comparison
When comparing the price of these two luxury mattresses, both the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Cloud are priced at the higher end of the spectrum. However, there are notable differences in pricing based on size and model. Here is a detailed breakdown of the price comparison:
| Mattress Size | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud | Price Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Twin XL | $2,199 | $1,699 | $500 |
| Full | $2,399 | $1,899 | $500 |
| Queen | $2,799 | $1,999 | $800 |
| King | $3,299 | $2,799 | $500 |
| California King | $3,299 | $2,799 | $500 |
The Beautyrest Black is generally more expensive than the Tempur-Cloud, particularly for larger sizes like Queen, King, and California King. However, the price reflects the advanced hybrid construction, reinforced edge support, and cooling features of the Beautyrest Black.
Warranty and Sleep Trials
Beautyrest Black
- Sleep Trial: 100-night sleep trial.
- Warranty: 10-year limited warranty.
- Shipping & Returns: Free white-glove delivery and setup. Beautyrest also offers free returns during the trial period.
Tempur-Cloud
- Sleep Trial: 90-night sleep trial.
- Warranty: 10-year limited warranty.
- Shipping & Returns: Bed-in-a-box delivery with a return fee if you decide to return the mattress during the trial period.
Both mattresses offer comprehensive warranty and trial periods, giving you ample time to test the mattress in your home. However, Beautyrest Black offers a slightly longer trial period and free returns, making it the more customer-friendly option in this regard.
Additional Factors: Off-Gassing, Noise, and Sex Suitability
Off-Gassing
Off-gassing is common with foam mattresses, particularly bed-in-a-box models. The Tempur-Cloud, being an all-foam mattress, may emit a mild chemical smell upon unboxing, but it should dissipate within a few days. The Beautyrest Black, with its hybrid construction, has less potential for off-gassing, though some mild smells may occur initially.
| Factor | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Off-Gassing | Minimal, dissipates quickly | May last a few days after unboxing |
Noise
The Tempur-Cloud is virtually silent, thanks to its all-foam construction. There are no moving parts or coils, so sleepers will experience no noise when shifting positions. The Beautyrest Black, despite being a hybrid with coils, is also quiet due to its individually pocketed coil system, which minimizes creaking and noise when you move.
| Factor | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Noise | Quiet, minimal noise | Silent |
Sex Suitability
When it comes to sex, many couples prefer a mattress that is responsive and easy to move around on. The Beautyrest Black performs well in this regard, thanks to the bounce provided by the pocketed coil system. The Tempur-Cloud, on the other hand, has a slow-moving memory foam feel that may make movement more difficult, but it offers excellent traction.
| Factor | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Suitability for Sex | Good bounce, easy movement | Less bounce, more traction |
Final Thoughts: Beautyrest Black vs. Tempur-Cloud
In conclusion, both the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Cloud are exceptional luxury mattresses that cater to different types of sleepers. The best choice ultimately depends on your personal preferences and sleep needs.
Choose Beautyrest Black if:
- You are a back or stomach sleeper who needs a firmer mattress for proper spinal alignment.
- You are a hot sleeper who needs a mattress with excellent temperature regulation.
- You prefer a bouncier, more responsive mattress that makes it easy to move around.
- You are a heavier individual who needs extra support and durability.
Choose Tempur-Cloud if:
- You are a side sleeper who needs pressure relief on the shoulders and hips.
- You enjoy the classic memory foam feel with deep contouring and motion isolation.
- You are a lightweight to average-weight sleeper who doesn’t need as much firmness or edge support.
- You are looking for a mattress with excellent motion isolation, especially if you share your bed with a partner.
Both mattresses come with solid warranties and sleep trials, so you can test them out and ensure they meet your sleep needs. Ultimately, if you prioritize temperature regulation, durability, and bounce, the Beautyrest Black may be the better option. However, if you prefer deep pressure relief, motion isolation, and the classic memory foam feel, the Tempur-Cloud is a great choice. When deciding between the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Cloud, it’s essential to weigh the features that matter most to your sleep experience. Let’s summarize the key differences:
| Feature | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Firmness | Medium-firm, more responsive | Medium-firm, slow-moving memory foam |
| Materials | Hybrid with coils and foam | All-foam construction |
| Best for | Back/stomach sleepers, hot sleepers, heavier people | Side sleepers, couples, foam lovers |
| Temperature Regulation | Excellent due to breathable coils and gel foam | Moderate, can retain heat |
| Motion Isolation | Good, but some transfer due to coils | Excellent for couples, isolates motion well |
| Edge Support | Strong reinforced edges, excellent for couples | Moderate, weaker compared to hybrids |
| Durability | High durability, especially for heavy people | High durability, may sag over time for heavier individuals |
| Noise | Quiet for a hybrid mattress | Completely silent due to all-foam design |
| Sex Suitability | Great for sex due to responsiveness and bounce | Moderate, slower movement but good traction |
| Off-Gassing | Minimal | Some off-gassing upon unboxing |
| Trial Period | 100-night sleep trial | 90-night sleep trial |
| Price | Higher price, luxury hybrid | Slightly lower price, luxury all-foam |
Recommendations for Different Sleepers
- Hot Sleepers: If you tend to overheat at night, the Beautyrest Black is the superior option due to its breathable coil system and gel memory foam that help regulate temperature. The Tempur-Cloud, while offering some cooling features, may retain heat, making it less ideal for hot sleepers.
- Couples: If you and your partner prioritize motion isolation, the Tempur-Cloud is the better choice due to its memory foam construction that absorbs movement. However, if you need adjustable firmness and strong edge support, the Beautyrest Black might be better suited for you.
- Heavy Sleepers: The Beautyrest Black provides excellent support for heavier individuals, especially due to its hybrid construction, which offers more resistance to sagging over time. The Tempur-Cloud may struggle to provide adequate support for sleepers over 230 lbs.
- Side Sleepers: The Tempur-Cloud excels at pressure relief, particularly for side sleepers who need extra cushioning around the shoulders and hips. The deep contouring of memory foam provides targeted pressure relief that can help alleviate joint pain.
- Back and Stomach Sleepers: For those who primarily sleep on their back or stomach, the Beautyrest Black offers more support and firmness, ensuring proper spinal alignment without excessive sinking.
- Foam Lovers: If you love the classic “sinking into the bed” feeling of memory foam, the Tempur-Cloud delivers this sensation beautifully, giving you a cradling effect that many foam enthusiasts enjoy.
Additional Features and Smart Technology
The Beautyrest Black does not have smart technology integrated into its models. However, it comes with advanced cooling features and edge support, making it highly appealing for those who prioritize comfort and durability in a traditional hybrid mattress.
The Tempur-Cloud, while not equipped with smart technology, shines with its ability to isolate motion, making it a great option for light sleepers or couples who share a bed.
Final Verdict
Both the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Cloud represent some of the best options in the luxury mattress market. Your final decision should be based on your sleep preferences, body type, and specific needs.
- Choose the Beautyrest Black if:
- You want a mattress with cooling properties.
- You prefer a bouncier, more responsive feel.
- You need strong edge support and durability for heavier sleepers.
- You sleep primarily on your back or stomach and require a firmer, supportive mattress.
- Choose the Tempur-Cloud if:
- You enjoy the classic memory foam feel with deep contouring.
- You are a side sleeper needing pressure relief on your shoulders and hips.
- You prioritize motion isolation and a quiet sleeping experience.
- You share the bed with a partner and want minimal movement transfer.
By carefully considering the features, performance, and price of both mattresses, you can select the one that will give you the most comfortable and restful night’s sleep.
Price Comparison
Both the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Cloud are luxury mattresses, but they differ significantly in price based on the size and model chosen.
| Size | Beautyrest Black Price | Tempur-Cloud Price | Price Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Twin XL | $2,319 | $1,999 | $320 |
| Full | $2,699 | $2,149 | $550 |
| Queen | $2,899 | $2,399 | $500 |
| King/California King | $3,499 | $2,999 | $500 |
While both mattresses are in the higher-end luxury price bracket, Beautyrest Black tends to be slightly more expensive, particularly in larger sizes. However, its added features like advanced edge support and hybrid construction may justify the higher price for some buyers.
Trial Period, Warranty, and Return Policies
A key consideration when purchasing a mattress is the trial period, warranty, and return policy. Both Tempur-Pedic and Beautyrest offer robust policies to give you peace of mind during your purchase.
| Feature | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Trial Period | 100-night sleep trial | 90-night sleep trial |
| Warranty | 10 years | 10 years |
| Return Policy | Free returns within trial period | Customer pays for return shipping |
| White Glove Delivery | Included with free mattress setup | Available for an additional fee |
While both brands provide solid warranties and sleep trials, Beautyrest Black offers slightly more favorable terms with a longer trial period and free returns. Tempur-Pedic, on the other hand, requires customers to cover return shipping costs but offers the benefit of white glove delivery for an extra fee.
Cooling Technology
For those who tend to overheat during the night, cooling technology is a significant factor in choosing the right mattress. Beautyrest Black excels in this area due to its gel memory foam and breathable coil system.
- Beautyrest Black: The hybrid construction incorporates BlackICE™ 4.0 Technology, a cooling system that combines a cool-to-the-touch cover with gel-infused foams. The coil support system also allows for better airflow, making this mattress ideal for hot sleepers.
- Tempur-Cloud: Tempur-Pedic uses TEMPUR-Breeze® Technology in its higher-end models to help dissipate heat. However, the Tempur-Cloud mattress lacks this advanced cooling technology, which may cause it to retain more heat than its hybrid counterparts.
Sex Suitability
An often overlooked factor in mattress selection is suitability for sex. A mattress that is responsive, easy to move around on, and provides good edge support can enhance the experience.
- Beautyrest Black: Thanks to its responsive coil system, the Beautyrest Black offers excellent bounce, making it a great option for sex. The strong edge support also allows couples to use the full surface of the mattress without feeling like they might roll off.
- Tempur-Cloud: While the Tempur-Cloud provides great traction due to its memory foam surface, it lacks the responsiveness that some couples may prefer. The slow-moving foam can make changing positions a bit more difficult, which might detract from the experience.
Off-Gassing and Noise
For eco-conscious buyers or those sensitive to smells, off-gassing is an important consideration.
- Beautyrest Black: Minimal off-gassing is reported with this mattress. While some initial odors may occur when first unpacked, these tend to dissipate quickly. The hybrid design also ensures that it is relatively quiet, with minimal noise from the coil system.
- Tempur-Cloud: As an all-foam mattress, the Tempur-Cloud may experience more noticeable off-gassing due to its memory foam materials. However, this smell should fade within a few days of unboxing. Being entirely foam-based, the mattress is completely silent during use, making it a good option for those sensitive to noise.
Durability and Maintenance
Both mattresses are built to last, but their construction affects their longevity.
- Beautyrest Black: The hybrid construction of Beautyrest Black offers superior durability, particularly for heavier sleepers. The reinforced edge support and high-quality materials make this mattress a long-term investment.
- Tempur-Cloud: While the Tempur-Cloud is durable, it may show signs of sagging over time, especially for heavier sleepers. Memory foam mattresses tend to lose their shape more quickly than hybrids, so proper care and rotating the mattress regularly can help extend its lifespan.
Maintenance Tips for Longevity
To ensure the longevity of either mattress, consider the following maintenance tips:
- Rotate the mattress every 3-6 months to prevent uneven wear.
- Use a mattress protector to prevent spills, stains, and allergens.
- For Tempur-Cloud, avoid jumping or applying excessive weight to one spot, as this could cause sagging.
- Clean the cover according to the manufacturer’s instructions to maintain hygiene and prevent dust build-up.
Final Thoughts: Which Mattress Is Right for You?
Both the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Cloud are excellent luxury mattresses, but they cater to different sleep preferences and needs.
- Choose the Beautyrest Black if you:
- Want a cooler sleeping surface with excellent airflow.
- Prefer a bouncier mattress that is easier to move around on.
- Need strong edge support and durability for heavier body types or couples.
- Are primarily a back or stomach sleeper and need firmer spinal support.
- Choose the Tempur-Cloud if you:
- Enjoy the deep contouring of memory foam and the feeling of sinking into your mattress.
- Need motion isolation to avoid disturbing your partner during the night.
- Are a side sleeper looking for pressure relief at the hips and shoulders.
- Prefer a quiet mattress that will remain silent during the night.
Comparison Table: Final Summary
| Feature | Beautyrest Black | Tempur-Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Firmness | Medium-firm, responsive | Medium-firm, slow-moving memory foam |
| Best for | Back/stomach sleepers, hot sleepers, heavier people | Side sleepers, couples, foam lovers |
| Temperature Regulation | Excellent due to gel foam and coils | Moderate, can retain heat |
| Edge Support | Strong reinforced edges, excellent for couples | Moderate, weaker edge support |
| Motion Isolation | Good, some transfer from coils | Excellent for couples, isolates motion well |
| Durability | Highly durable, hybrid construction | Durable but may sag with heavier use |
| Noise | Quiet for a hybrid mattress | Completely silent due to all-foam design |
| Sex Suitability | Great for sex due to responsiveness and bounce | Moderate, slow-moving foam but good traction |
| Price Range | Higher-end, luxury hybrid | Slightly more affordable luxury foam |
Ultimately, your choice between the Beautyrest Black and Tempur-Cloud depends on your sleep style, comfort preferences, and budget. By considering factors like cooling needs, motion isolation, and firmness preferences, you can choose the mattress that will provide you with the best sleep experience for years to come.